Cost-benefit analysis of different fattening systems with Tuj and Hemşin lambs in controlled conditions
Öz
This study aims to determine the most profitable fattening system through an economic analysis of lamb fattening in different fattening systems under controlled conditions which was performed for the first time in Turkey. The material of the study consists of 39 weaned lambs of 2.5-3 months old from each of the Tuj and Hemşin genotypes. In the study, the lambs were separated into the 3 fattening groups of extensive, semi-intensive and intensive including 13 Tuj and 13 Hemşin lambs in each group through the systematic sampling method in a diagonal manner and these lambs were subject to 90 days-fattening. As a result of the economic analysis, the daily cost per animal, and output/input ratio for Tuj lambs in the extensive, semi-intensive, and intensive fattening systems were respectively determined to be ₺ 0.94 TL-1.05, ₺ 1.69 TL-1.20, and ₺ 1.99 TL-1.12 and the same values were respectively determined to be ₺ 0.95 TL-1.04, ₺ 1.70 TL-1.11, and ₺ 2.00 TL-1.09 for Hemşin lambs. All the fattening systems are statistically different from each other in the fattening of Tuj and Hemşin lambs in terms of total costs (P<0.001). On the other hand, a statistically significant difference was determined between the extensive fattening system and other fattening systems in terms of net profit and output/input ratios (P<0.001). In conclusion, as the total costs, 1 kg carcass, 1 kg live weight gain, and 1 kg live weight costs are lower; on the other hand, as net profit and input/output ratios in the semi-intensive fattening system are higher compared to the intensive fattening system, for Tuj and Hemşin lambs the semi-intensive fattening system is recommended
Anahtar Kelimeler
Kaynakça
- Akcapinar H (2000): Sheep Breeding (in Turkish), 2nd Edition, Ismat Publishing, Ankara.
- Aksu Elmali D, Demir P, Kaya İ (2010): Cost-benefit analyses of feeding with different concentrate feeds in Tuj (Tushin) lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 16, 771-775.
- Aydin E (2011): Economic analysis of intensive fattening enterprises in the provinces of Kars and Erzurum. Ankara University, Institute of Health Sciences, Doctoral Thesis, Ankara.
- Aydin E, Aral Y, Can MF, et al. (2011): Analysis of the red meat price changes over the last 25 years and effects of import decisions in Turkey. Vet Hek Der Derg, 82, 3-13.
- Aydin E, Sakarya E (2012): Economic analysis of intensive cattle fattening enterprises in the provinces of Kars and Erzurum. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 18, 997- 1005.
- Aydin E, Sari M, Onk K, et al. (2014): Determination of the optimum fattening period of Tuj and Hemşin lambs according to different fattening systems. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 20, 835-840.
- Cevger Y (1997): Analysis of profitability and productivity of lamb fattening enterprises in Karaman province. Vet J Ankara Univ, 44, 277-290.
- Cevger Y, Aral Y, Demir P, et al. (2008): The situation of animal products consumption and consumer preferences among intern students at the Ankara University Faculty of Veterinary Medicine. Vet J Ankara Univ, 55, 189-194.
- Ekiz B, Yilmaz A, Ozcan M, et al. (2009): Carcass measurements and meat quality of Turkish Merino, Ramlic, Kivircik, Chios and Imroz lambs raised under an intensive production system. Meat Sci, 82, 64-70.
- FAOSAT (2016): Food and Agriculture Organization, Animal Production Statistics, http://faostat.fao.org/site/569/ default.aspx#ancor, Access Date: 04.04.2016
- Hartwell BW, Iniguez L, Knaus WF, et al. (2010): Awassi lamb growth responses and carcass traits, and economic benefits associated with reduced-cost diets made from locally available feed resources, Small Ruminant Res, 93, 48-52.
- Işık S, Kaya İ (2011): The effect of vegetation period on the qualilty of pasture and performance of grazing Tujhin sheep and lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 17, 7-11.
- Kars Trade Exchange (2012): Live animals and animal products prices. http://www.karstb.org.tr, Access Date: 15.12.2012
- Kaygisiz F, Elmaz O, Keser O (2006): The impacts of weight and price margins on the incomes in Kivircik lamb fattening. J Fac Vet Med Istanbul Univ, 32, 53-58.
- Rihawi S, Iniguez L, Knaus WF, et al. (2010): Fattening performance of lambs of different Awassi genotypes, fed under cost-reducing diets and contrasting housing conditions. Small Ruminant Res, 94, 38-44.
- Sakarya E (1998): The importance and sheep husbandry in Turkey (in Turkish). Journal of Ekin, 2, 33-37.
- Sakarya E, Gunlu A (1996): A study on determination of optimal fattening period of Limuzin X Jersey cross-breeds and Holstein bulls, Vet J Ankara Univ, 43, 113-120.
- Sari M, Aksoy AR, Tilki M, et al. (2012): Effect of different fattening methods on slaughter and carcass characteristics of Tuj male lambs. Arch Tierzucht, 55, 480- 484.
- Sari M, Onk K, Aydin E, et al. (2014): Effects of different fattening systems on fattening performance and body measurements of Hemsin male lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 20, 209-215.
- Sari M, Onk K, Aksoy AR, et al. (2015): Effects of different fattening systems on slaughter and carcass traits of male Hemsin lambs. Vet J Ankara Univ, 62, 147-152.
- Sezgin E, Kopuzlu S, Yüksel S, et al. (2012): Determination of growth traits and heritabilities of growth characteristics of Hemşin sheep reared in Artvin. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 18, 899-905.
- SPSS (2012): For windows, 2012: Release 20.0. Standard version. Copyright SPSS Inc. 23. TURKSTAT (2016): Turkish Livestock Statistics. https://biruni.tuik.gov.tr/hayvancilik app/hayvancilik.zul, Access Date: 04.04.2016. Institute, Geliş tarihi: 03.02.2014 / Kabul tarihi: 15.06.2016 Address for correspondence: Assist. Prof. Dr. Erol AYDIN Kafkas University, Veterinary Medicine Faculty Department of Livestock Economics and Management TR - 36300, Kars, Turkey. Tel: +90 474 2426807/5099 e-mail: dr-erolaydin@hotmail.com
Kontrollü koşullarda Tuj ve Hemşin kuzularıyla yapılan farklı besi sistemlerinin fayda/maliyet analizi
Öz
Bu araştırma ile Türkiye’de ilk defa kontrollü koşullar altında farklı besi sistemlerinde kuzu beslemenin ekonomik analizi yapılarak, en karlı olan besi sisteminin belirlenmesi amaçlanmıştır. Araştırma materyalini Tuj ve Hemşin genotiplerinden 2.5-3 aylık yaşta sütten kesilmiş, 39’ar baş erkek kuzu oluşturmuştur. Çalışmada kuzular sistematik örnekleme metoduyla çapraz olarak her grupta 13 baş Tuj ve 13 baş Hemşin olacak şekilde ekstansif, yarı entansif ve entansif olmak üzere 3 farklı besi grubuna ayrılmış ve 90 günlük besiye tabi tutulmuştur. Ekonomik analiz sonucunda Tuj kuzularında ekstansif, yarı-entasif ve entansif besi sistemlerine göre hayvan başına günlük maliyet ve output/input oranı sırasıyla ₺ 0.94 TL-1.05, ₺ 1.69 TL-1.20 ve ₺ 1.99 TL-1.12 iken, aynı değerler Hemşin kuzularında ise sırasıyla ₺ 0.95 TL-1.04, ₺ 1.70 TL-1.11 ve ₺ 2.00 TL-1.09 olarak tespit edilmiştir. Tuj ve Hemşin kuzularının besisinde toplam masraflar yönünden bütün besi sistemleri birbirinden istatistik olarak farklıdır (P<0.001). Diğer taraftan net kar ile output/input oranı açısından ise ekstansif besi sistemi ve diğer besi sistemleri arasında istatistik olarak anlamlı bir fark tespit edilmiştir (P<0.001). Sonuç olarak; entansif besi sistemine göre yarı-entasif besi sisteminde toplam masrafların, 1 kg karkas, 1 kg canlı ağırlık artışı ve 1 kg canlı ağırlık maliyetinin daha az oluşu ve diğer taraftan net karın, output/input oranının daha fazla olması nedeniyle Tuj ve Hemşin kuzuları için yarı-entansif besi sistemi önerilmektedir
Anahtar Kelimeler
Kaynakça
- Akcapinar H (2000): Sheep Breeding (in Turkish), 2nd Edition, Ismat Publishing, Ankara.
- Aksu Elmali D, Demir P, Kaya İ (2010): Cost-benefit analyses of feeding with different concentrate feeds in Tuj (Tushin) lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 16, 771-775.
- Aydin E (2011): Economic analysis of intensive fattening enterprises in the provinces of Kars and Erzurum. Ankara University, Institute of Health Sciences, Doctoral Thesis, Ankara.
- Aydin E, Aral Y, Can MF, et al. (2011): Analysis of the red meat price changes over the last 25 years and effects of import decisions in Turkey. Vet Hek Der Derg, 82, 3-13.
- Aydin E, Sakarya E (2012): Economic analysis of intensive cattle fattening enterprises in the provinces of Kars and Erzurum. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 18, 997- 1005.
- Aydin E, Sari M, Onk K, et al. (2014): Determination of the optimum fattening period of Tuj and Hemşin lambs according to different fattening systems. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 20, 835-840.
- Cevger Y (1997): Analysis of profitability and productivity of lamb fattening enterprises in Karaman province. Vet J Ankara Univ, 44, 277-290.
- Cevger Y, Aral Y, Demir P, et al. (2008): The situation of animal products consumption and consumer preferences among intern students at the Ankara University Faculty of Veterinary Medicine. Vet J Ankara Univ, 55, 189-194.
- Ekiz B, Yilmaz A, Ozcan M, et al. (2009): Carcass measurements and meat quality of Turkish Merino, Ramlic, Kivircik, Chios and Imroz lambs raised under an intensive production system. Meat Sci, 82, 64-70.
- FAOSAT (2016): Food and Agriculture Organization, Animal Production Statistics, http://faostat.fao.org/site/569/ default.aspx#ancor, Access Date: 04.04.2016
- Hartwell BW, Iniguez L, Knaus WF, et al. (2010): Awassi lamb growth responses and carcass traits, and economic benefits associated with reduced-cost diets made from locally available feed resources, Small Ruminant Res, 93, 48-52.
- Işık S, Kaya İ (2011): The effect of vegetation period on the qualilty of pasture and performance of grazing Tujhin sheep and lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 17, 7-11.
- Kars Trade Exchange (2012): Live animals and animal products prices. http://www.karstb.org.tr, Access Date: 15.12.2012
- Kaygisiz F, Elmaz O, Keser O (2006): The impacts of weight and price margins on the incomes in Kivircik lamb fattening. J Fac Vet Med Istanbul Univ, 32, 53-58.
- Rihawi S, Iniguez L, Knaus WF, et al. (2010): Fattening performance of lambs of different Awassi genotypes, fed under cost-reducing diets and contrasting housing conditions. Small Ruminant Res, 94, 38-44.
- Sakarya E (1998): The importance and sheep husbandry in Turkey (in Turkish). Journal of Ekin, 2, 33-37.
- Sakarya E, Gunlu A (1996): A study on determination of optimal fattening period of Limuzin X Jersey cross-breeds and Holstein bulls, Vet J Ankara Univ, 43, 113-120.
- Sari M, Aksoy AR, Tilki M, et al. (2012): Effect of different fattening methods on slaughter and carcass characteristics of Tuj male lambs. Arch Tierzucht, 55, 480- 484.
- Sari M, Onk K, Aydin E, et al. (2014): Effects of different fattening systems on fattening performance and body measurements of Hemsin male lambs. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 20, 209-215.
- Sari M, Onk K, Aksoy AR, et al. (2015): Effects of different fattening systems on slaughter and carcass traits of male Hemsin lambs. Vet J Ankara Univ, 62, 147-152.
- Sezgin E, Kopuzlu S, Yüksel S, et al. (2012): Determination of growth traits and heritabilities of growth characteristics of Hemşin sheep reared in Artvin. Kafkas Univ Vet Fak Derg, 18, 899-905.
- SPSS (2012): For windows, 2012: Release 20.0. Standard version. Copyright SPSS Inc. 23. TURKSTAT (2016): Turkish Livestock Statistics. https://biruni.tuik.gov.tr/hayvancilik app/hayvancilik.zul, Access Date: 04.04.2016. Institute, Geliş tarihi: 03.02.2014 / Kabul tarihi: 15.06.2016 Address for correspondence: Assist. Prof. Dr. Erol AYDIN Kafkas University, Veterinary Medicine Faculty Department of Livestock Economics and Management TR - 36300, Kars, Turkey. Tel: +90 474 2426807/5099 e-mail: dr-erolaydin@hotmail.com
Ayrıntılar
| Birincil Dil | İngilizce |
|---|---|
| Konular | Veteriner Cerrahi |
| Diğer ID | JA97NJ87BR |
| Bölüm | Araştırma Makalesi |
| Yazarlar | |
| Yayımlanma Tarihi | 1 Eylül 2017 |
| Yayımlandığı Sayı | Yıl 2017Cilt: 64 Sayı: 3 |